// ARS TECHNICA — INTELLIGENZA ARTIFICIALE
NOAA is putting commercial fishing ahead of conservation
Critics say the new agenda could weaken science-based rules and marine protections.
In July, the Trump administration relegated endangered leatherback turtles, sea lions, and whales to mere collateral damage in its race to profit from the oceans. Now, fisheries science is in the government’s crosshairs.
The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) announced new agency priorities last week that they say are a commitment to “cutting bureaucracy, modernizing our science, and putting our fishing communities first.” But experts say the agency’s actions will erode fish stocks, threaten endangered species, and surrender marine habitats to destructive trawlers.
The agency-level reforms serve as a self-proclaimed “operational roadmap” to fulfilling President Donald Trump’s “Restoring American Seafood Competitiveness” executive order, signed in April 2025.
On the table: opening marine national monuments to commercial fishing operations, scaling back critical habitat designations to focus more on the downstream economics of conservation, and weakening decades of peer-reviewed science.
“If you asked AI to come up with a plan to hollow out marine ecosystems and impoverish coastal communities, it would look a lot like the one NOAA just put out,” said Andrea Treece, the senior attorney in the Oceans Program at Earthjustice, in an email to Inside Climate News. “The agency is taking a sharp turn away from science.”
The announcement comes after letters were sent to regional fisheries councils earlier in the summer, directing them to dismantle restrictions in favor of more permissive, economically advantageous fishing procedures.
“It’s inexcusable for the administration to make it easier to destroy marine habitats and commit endangered species to extinction in the name of short-term profits,” said Treece. “You can’t just eliminate parts of the ecosystem you find inconvenient and expect that system to continue to sustain us.”
While this latest development includes some of the same policy agenda—such as shelving the implementation of ropeless gear designed to protect the last 350 North Atlantic right whales from entanglement—it also includes a proposed overhaul to the guiding principles of fisheries management.
Last week’s statement ordered re-evaluations of multiple “National Standards” with an eye to possible amendments or supplementations. National standards are the 10 principles mandated by the 1976 Magnuson-Stevens Act to ensure sustainable and responsible fisheries management in US waters.